Insights

Who takes the certification decision, and why it is not the audit team

The certification decision is taken by the certification body, through a person or committee that did not carry out the audit.

Published by CAS — Conformity Assessment Services · 16 November 2026 · 5 min read
ShareLinkedInFacebook
Who takes the certification decision, and why it is not the audit team

Key takeaways

  1. 1Not part of the audit. §9.5.1.1, as above.
  2. 2Competent. Under §7.2.8, they understand the applicable standard and the certification requirements, and have demonstrated competence to evaluate the outcomes of the audit processes, including the audit team's recommendations.
  3. 3Within the body's control. §9.5.1.2 requires a person who decides to be employed by, or under a legally enforceable arrangement with, the certification body or an entity under its organizational control. Committee members are excluded from that condition; committees work under the body's formal rules (§6.1.4). §7.5.2 adds that certification decisions are not outsourced.
  4. 4Impartial. §5.2.12 requires everyone who could influence the certification activities, including committees, to act impartially and not to let commercial, financial or other pressures compromise impartiality.

The certification decision is taken by the certification body, through a person or committee that did not carry out the audit. ISO/IEC 17021-1 §9.5.1.1 requires those who decide on granting or refusing certification, expanding or reducing its scope, suspending or restoring, withdrawing or renewing it to be "different from those who carried out the audits". The audit team concludes and recommends. Someone else decides, on the written record.

What the audit team hands over

Before the closing meeting, the team classifies the nonconformities and agrees its conclusions, "taking into account the uncertainty inherent in the audit process" (§9.4.6). The closing meeting presents those conclusions, "including the recommendation regarding certification" (§9.4.7.1), and the audit report records the recommendation (§9.4.8.2 p)).

A recommendation is an input, not the decision. Under §5.1.3 the certification body is responsible for its certification decisions and retains authority for them.

Who may decide

ISO/IEC 17021-1 sets four conditions on the person or committee that decides.

  • Not part of the audit. §9.5.1.1, as above.
  • Competent. Under §7.2.8, they understand the applicable standard and the certification requirements, and have demonstrated competence to evaluate the outcomes of the audit processes, including the audit team's recommendations.
  • Within the body's control. §9.5.1.2 requires a person who decides to be employed by, or under a legally enforceable arrangement with, the certification body or an entity under its organizational control. Committee members are excluded from that condition; committees work under the body's formal rules (§6.1.4). §7.5.2 adds that certification decisions are not outsourced.
  • Impartial. §5.2.12 requires everyone who could influence the certification activities, including committees, to act impartially and not to let commercial, financial or other pressures compromise impartiality.

What the separation protects

The clause gives no reason. The reason shows in what the rest of the standard builds around it.

The evidence has to be on the record. A decision-maker who did not carry out the audit works from what was recorded. Findings are recorded "to enable an informed certification decision to be made" (§9.4.5.1). A nonconformity is recorded against a specific requirement, with the objective evidence it rests on (§9.4.5.3). The report has to be an accurate, concise and clear record for the same purpose (§9.4.8.2). An observation that was never recorded is not part of the file the decision-maker reviews.

The recommendation is tested, not ratified. The decision-maker must be competent to evaluate the team's recommendations (§7.2.8), which matters only if a recommendation can be questioned. §9.5.1.4 provides for that: each decision is recorded, including any additional information or clarification sought from the audit team or other sources.

Disagreements reach someone outside them. The audit team leader tries to resolve diverging opinions with the client (§9.4.5.4). What is still unresolved after the closing meeting is recorded and referred to the certification body (§9.4.7.3), and the report includes any unresolved issues (§9.4.8.2 m)).

What the decision-maker looks at

For initial certification, §9.5.3.1 sets the minimum the audit team provides:

  • the audit report;
  • comments on the nonconformities and, where applicable, on the correction and corrective actions the client has taken;
  • confirmation of the information used in the application review (§9.1.2);
  • confirmation that the audit objectives have been achieved;
  • a recommendation on whether to grant certification, with any conditions or observations.

§9.5.2 then requires an effective review before the decision, including three named points:

  • the audit team's information is sufficient for the certification requirements and the scope for certification;
  • for any major nonconformity, the body has reviewed, accepted and verified the correction and corrective actions;
  • for any minor nonconformity, the body has reviewed and accepted the client's plan for correction and corrective action.

Correction and corrective action on a major nonconformity have to be verified before the decision. For a minor one, an accepted plan is what the review requires.

Scope is part of the decision too: the report concludes on whether the certification scope is appropriate (§9.4.8.3 b)).

How decision-makers' competence differs from auditors'

In Table A.1 of the normative Annex A, the function of reviewing audit reports and making certification decisions carries four areas of knowledge: audit principles, the management system standard, the body's own processes and the client's business sector. The auditing function adds business management practices, the client's products, processes and organization, and the audit skills, from interviewing and report writing to audit management.

The depth differs too. An auditor's knowledge of the standard must be enough to determine whether it has been effectively implemented (A.2.3). A decision-maker's must be enough "to make a decision on the basis of a certification audit report" (A.3.2), and their knowledge of the body's processes enough to judge, from the information submitted for review, whether the body's expectations have been met (A.3.3).

The decision-maker is not asked to re-audit. They read the record against the requirements and decide whether it is enough.

Where the separation is relaxed

§9.6.1 lets a certification body maintain a client's certification on the audit team leader's positive conclusion, without a further independent review and decision, on two conditions. The team leader reports any major nonconformity, or other situation that may lead to suspension or withdrawal, so that competent personnel who did not carry out the audit review it. And competent personnel monitor the surveillance activities, including the auditors' reporting.

This covers maintaining certification only. Every decision listed in §9.5.1.1, from granting to renewing, stays with people who did not carry out the audit.

What this means for you

If you are being audited: the recommendation at the closing meeting is the audit team's. The decision is taken by someone who did not carry out the audit, on what the report and your nonconformity responses show.

If you are responding to nonconformities: for a major nonconformity, the decision waits until correction and corrective action are verified (§9.5.2 b)). For a minor one, the plan has to be reviewed and accepted (§9.5.2 c)).

If you are a buyer: an accredited certificate was granted under these rules, by people who did not carry out the audit.

This is generic information about the requirement, not advice on any particular management system.

CAS — An EGAC accredited MS certification body No. 012418. Accredited scope: ISO 9001, ISO 14001, ISO 45001, ISO 22000, ISO 50001 and ISO 22301. Certificates accredited for ISO 9001, 14001, 45001, 22000 and 50001 fall within EGAC's IAF MLA scope; ISO 22301 is accredited by EGAC and sits outside that scope.

Verify any certificate: cas.com.eg/certsearch

Apply for certification →Verify a certificate

Read next