Key takeaways
- 1Nonconformity (3.11): "non-fulfilment of a requirement".
- 2Major nonconformity (3.12): a nonconformity that affects the capability of the management system to achieve the intended results.
- 3Minor nonconformity (3.13): a nonconformity that does not affect that capability.
A nonconformity is a requirement that is not met. ISO/IEC 17021-1:2015 grades it by one test: does it affect the capability of the management system to achieve the intended results? If it does, it is major. If it does not, it is minor. Both grades need correction and corrective action. What the grade changes is what the certification body must see before it decides, and how much time the standard allows.
The definitions
ISO/IEC 17021-1 defines three terms in clause 3:
- Nonconformity (3.11): "non-fulfilment of a requirement".
- Major nonconformity (3.12): a nonconformity that affects the capability of the management system to achieve the intended results.
- Minor nonconformity (3.13): a nonconformity that does not affect that capability.
A note to 3.12 gives two circumstances in which a nonconformity could be classified as major:
- significant doubt about whether effective process control is in place, or whether products or services will meet specified requirements;
- several minor nonconformities on the same requirement or issue that together could show a systemic failure, and so amount to a major one.
The test is the system's capability, not the size of the single event. The note says "could": its circumstances can lead to a major grade, but the test stays the one in the definition. And several minors on the same requirement or issue can be read together as one major.
For ISO 50001 certification, ISO 50003:2021 §3.6 repeats the definition for the energy management system and adds one example: audit evidence that energy performance improvement was not achieved.
Who grades, and when
The audit team classifies the nonconformities before the closing meeting, under the audit team leader's responsibility (§9.4.6 a)). Each one is recorded against a specific requirement, with the objective evidence it rests on (§9.4.5.3). At the closing meeting, the certification body explains its process for handling nonconformities, including any consequences for the status of the client's certification (§9.4.7.2 c)). A note to §9.4.7.1 adds that a nonconformity being understood does not necessarily mean the client has accepted it.
Two other outputs of an audit are not nonconformities. An opportunity for improvement may be recorded, but a finding that is a nonconformity shall not be recorded as one (§9.4.5.2). At stage 1, the conclusions identify areas of concern that could be classified as a nonconformity during stage 2 (§9.3.1.2.3).
Where the grade makes a difference
The client's first step is the same for both grades: analyse the cause and describe the specific correction and corrective actions, taken or planned, within a defined time (§9.4.9). The difference shows at each point in the certification cycle.
At initial certification. Before the decision, the certification body must have reviewed, accepted and verified the correction and corrective actions for any major nonconformity, and reviewed and accepted the client's plan for any minor one (§9.5.2 b) and c)). If it cannot verify the implementation of the actions on a major nonconformity within 6 months after the last day of stage 2, it conducts another stage 2 before recommending certification (§9.5.3.2).
At surveillance. A certification body may maintain certification on the audit team leader's positive conclusion, without a further independent review, under two conditions. One is that for any major nonconformity, or other situation that may lead to suspension or withdrawal, the team leader reports the need for a review by competent personnel who did not carry out the audit, to determine whether certification can be maintained (§9.6.1 a)). Every surveillance audit also reviews the actions taken on nonconformities identified at the previous audit (§9.6.2.2 b)), so a minor accepted on a plan is followed up at a later audit.
At recertification. For any major nonconformity, the certification body defines time limits for correction and corrective actions, and those actions are implemented and verified before the certification expires (§9.6.3.2.2). If they are not verified before the expiry date, recertification is not recommended and the validity of the certification is not extended (§9.6.3.2.4). For a minor nonconformity, the renewal decision needs the same as the initial one: an accepted plan (§9.5.2 c)).
Suspension. §9.6.5.2 does not tie suspension to the grade of a single finding. Its first example is a certified management system that has "persistently or seriously failed" to meet certification requirements, including those for effectiveness (§9.6.5.2). Whether a case reaches that point is decided under the certification body's own policy and procedures (§9.6.5.1), by people who did not carry out the audit (§9.5.1.1).
The time limits in one place
- Responding to any nonconformity: the timeframe agreed at the closing meeting (§9.4.7.1), within a defined time (§9.4.9).
- Major, initial certification: actions verified within 6 months after the last day of stage 2, or another stage 2 (§9.5.3.2).
- Major, recertification: a time limit set by the certification body, and in any case before the certification expires (§9.6.3.2.2).
- Major, surveillance: no number in the standard.
- Minor: no number in the standard. The plan is accepted before a grant or renewal decision (§9.5.2 c)).
For ISO 22000 and ISO 50001, the sector standards call up the same ISO/IEC 17021-1 clauses on the decision and on maintaining certification (ISO 22003-1:2022 §9.5 and §9.6; ISO 50003:2021 §9.5 and §9.6). ISO 50003 adds its own requirements on energy performance improvement.
What this means for you
If you are answering a major nonconformity: after stage 2, the actions are verified within 6 months of its last day, or another stage 2 is needed; at recertification, within the certification body's time limit and before the expiry date. At surveillance, a major is reported for review by people who did not carry out the audit.
If you are answering minor nonconformities: an accepted plan is what the decision needs, and what was done is reviewed at a later audit. Several minors on the same requirement or issue can be graded as one major.
If you are a buyer: a certificate does not mean that no nonconformities were found. It means that, when certification was granted or renewed, any major nonconformity had verified actions and any minor one an accepted plan.
This is generic information about the requirement, not advice on any particular management system.
CAS — An EGAC accredited MS certification body No. 012418. Accredited scope: ISO 9001, ISO 14001, ISO 45001, ISO 22000, ISO 50001 and ISO 22301. Certificates accredited for ISO 9001, 14001, 45001, 22000 and 50001 fall within EGAC's IAF MLA scope; ISO 22301 is accredited by EGAC and sits outside that scope.
Verify any certificate: cas.com.eg/certsearch
Read next